Crows and blue jays are two common backyard birds found throughout much of North America. They both belong to the Corvid family, which includes ravens, magpies, and jays. Despite their similarities, crows and blue jays have a complex relationship that features both cooperation and conflict. In this article, we’ll explore the interactions between these intelligent birds and try to answer the question: do crows and blue jays get along?
Basic facts about crows and blue jays
Before diving into their relationship, let’s review some quick facts about crows and blue jays:
Crows
- There are several species, the most common being the American Crow.
- Highly intelligent birds known for problem-solving skills.
- Omnivorous and opportunistic eaters.
- Live in family groups with complex social structures.
- Make a wide range of “caw” vocalizations.
Blue jays
- Blue jays are songbirds in the Corvid family.
- Known for their bright blue plumage and raucous “jay jay” call.
- Omnivores that eat nuts, seeds, fruits, insects and even small vertebrates.
- More solitary than crows but do mate for life.
- Highly territorial and aggressive in defending resources.
As you can see, crows and blue jays share many traits common to Corvids, including intelligence, vocalizations, and omnivorous diets. But they differ in their social structures, with crows being more family-oriented and jays more solitary. This influences how they interact.
Competition between crows and blue jays
Crows and blue jays frequently come into conflict over shared food resources. As omnivores, they compete for many of the same nuts, seeds, fruits, and invertebrates. Because both species tend to forage in mixed flocks with their own kind, there is inevitable competition when flocks converge on a food bonanza.
Several studies have shown that jays will actively harass and try to displace crow flocks from food sources. Blue jays are known for their aggressive defense of resources, especially in winter when food is scarce. They will mob, dive-bomb, and even physically attack crows that are feeding in their territory. Crows tend to retreat from these assaults.
However, crows have their own intimidating mobbing strategy. When threatened by jays at a food source, a murder of crows may band together and mob the jays as a defensive flock. Crows mobbing a solitary blue jay can be an effective deterrent. But against multiple jays, the crows usually back down.
Overall, blue jays tend to dominate crows in skirmishes over food. Their aggressive territoriality gives them an edge. But crows are adaptable. Research shows that over time, crows learn to avoid areas where they have been attacked by jays. This reduces conflict and allows the species to coexist.
Cooperation between crows and blue jays
Despite the competition, there are also surprising areas of cooperation between crows and blue jays. One example is their role as alarm callers for each other.
Both species have complex alarm call systems that warn of potential predators like hawks and cats. Studies have found that crows and jays will make their alarm calls in response to predators even when no birds of their own species are present. This benefits birds of both species who can take evasive action.
Crows and jays have also been observed directly mobbing predators together. A sentinel jay that spots a perched hawk may begin mobbing and calling, which summons crows to join in the harassment. This cooperative mobbing helps drive predators away from nests and young.
There is also evidence that crows and jays watch and learn foraging strategies from each other. Young birds of both species have been observed picking up food handling techniques by watching the other species. This type of observational learning between rival species is rare in the animal kingdom.
Loose social associations
While crows and jays do not directly associate with each other for social reasons, loose affiliations between the species sometimes occur near abundant food sources.
Research shows crows and jays may form temporary multi-species flocks in areas like orchards where fruits and nuts are plentiful. As both species forage peacefully, the presence of more birds scanning for predators provides increased safety. This is especially important when raising vulnerable fledglings.
These temporary commingling flocks dissolve as soon as the food source declines. But the gatherings suggest crows and jays are capable of opportunistic cooperation when it benefits both species. Their intelligence allows them to calculate when it makes sense to coexist amicably.
Nesting near each other
Given their territoriality and aggression near feeding grounds, you might not expect crows and jays to nest in close proximity. But various studies reveal they often do nest near each other, likely for protection.
Research shows jays preferentially establish nests near crow colonies during breeding season. The crows provide an early warning system against predators. And by nesting adjacent to crows, the jays can remain close to their own foraging territories.
Crows also appear tolerant of jays nesting on the periphery of their breeding grounds. Again, the jays offer extra predator detection with their loud alarm calls. And the crows can chase jays away from food sources while still benefiting from their presence near the nest.
Intelligence and adaptation
The complex relationship between crows and jays ultimately reflects their advanced intelligence and adaptability. Both species have evolved the cognitive capacity to determine when to compete and when to cooperate based on circumstances.
Crows appear able to recognize individual jays that have attacked them and hold grudges. But they will cooperate against a predator. Jays ruthlessly defend food resources, yet partner with crows for mobbing. This nuanced decision-making suggests crows and jays have a conditional tolerance for each other modulated by their own self-interest.
The territorial jays seem more overtly aggressive. But the social crows likely exert their own dominance in ways that aren’t easily observed. Both species are constantly adapting their behaviors toward one another in an ever-shifting balance of risk and reward. Their intelligence explains why they can be both rival and ally.
Regional variations
It’s important to note that interactions between crows and jays vary across different regions. Some types of jays are far more aggressive than others. And default social tolerances can differ between habitats.
For example, in the Pacific Northwest, the local Steller’s jays are known to be antagonistic bullies toward crows and other birds. Crows nesting near Steller’s jays likely experience more hostility from them.
In the American Southeast, blue jay subspecies are less aggressive than northern jays. Here, crows and jays have been observed nesting in even tighter proximity with fewer conflicts. More research is needed to understand these regional social variations.
Conclusion
To summarize, the evidence suggests crows and blue jays have a complex relationship that combines competition, cooperation, and coexistence modulated by intelligence, self-interest, and regional behaviors. They are rival species competing for food and breeding resources. But their also opportunistic allies that cooperate against shared threats while generally tolerating each other near nesting sites.
The crows’ more social nature and the jays’ aggressive territoriality certainly influence day-to-day interactions. Where food is abundant, they form temporary mixed flocks. Where it’s scarce, jays attack crows. But their capacity to adapt allows a nuanced relationship with both rivalry and mutualism existing in different contexts.
So, do crows and blue jays get along? The answer is complicated, but suggests that self-interest ultimately wins out. Their limited cooperation arises when both species benefit in ways that outweigh the costs of tolerating a rival. Conflict occurs when resources are scarce. This shifting and context-dependent relationship speaks to the remarkable intelligence displayed by both crows and jays as they navigate their complex coexistence.
| Crow Traits | Blue Jay Traits |
|---|---|
|
|
